Wednesday, November 9, 2022

Let's do a HHOF mailbag

Hey folks...

Hit me with the players you think should be in or out, questions about who deserves it, how the system should work or anything else on your mind. Send questions via email at dgbmailbag@gmail.com.

Thanks,
Sean




91 comments:

  1. What would happen if a team went for only 5’9 high skill and speedy players

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What is the worst phrase uttered by sports announcers and why is it "getting untracked"? Don't they really mean "getting on track" and wouldn't that be a better and more sane thing to say and please Gord can you make them stop?

    ReplyDelete
  4. What is the worst move that won't happen this off season? Left deliberately vague to give you some leeway in answering.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Which team stands to be the Florida of this coming expansion draft and overpay like crazy to rid themselves of non-problems in a bid to get worse themselves

    ReplyDelete
  6. What is the longest trade tree you could make for an active NHL player? Like, could you somehow link someone like Phil Kessel to Newsy Lalonde?

    ReplyDelete
  7. When did players named Anthony stop going by "Tony", and why?

    ReplyDelete
  8. If you were going to produce a show about this past Leafs season, what would you call it and how would you structure the central plot? Would you emphasize the regular season success? How would you frame the playoffs?

    ReplyDelete
  9. If you're not allowed to make a line change after an icing, why is a goalie allowed to go back in net if he was off for an EN opportunity?

    ReplyDelete
  10. What would happen if the IIHF was as loose as FIFA with nationality rules for national teams?

    ReplyDelete
  11. The greatest trade ever made involving a player that never played for a team that was involved. Like Martin Jones for Boston before he was shipped to the Sharks. Except not that because we know how that turned out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. while the end was bad for jones he was a really good goalie for us for quite a few years, would still do that trade in hindsight, just not the extention he got!

      Delete
  12. Who is the best team of players you could assemble who have never received a fighting major?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Do you think the NHL should put in a rule you can no longer ice the puck on a penalty kill? I’ve always wondered why a team should be rewarded for taking a penalty by being able to brake one of the games more basic rules. It’d certainly increase scoring.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Unsure if this is possible to quantify properly, but which star player's career was most hampered by his team's inability to be close to competitive. (Think Mcdavid's trajectory) Whether it was happenstance, mismanagement, or anything else, who will we look back on as being not as good as we remember because they were on the worst teams?

    ReplyDelete
  15. Will the NHL take growing the NHL brand more seriously in a post-COVID world? They were doing the NHL Europe series for a while, but I'm thinking outside of Europe where ice hockey is already popular. Maybe somewhere in Asia (very selfishly thinking Australia where the game could take off with the right investment)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. already in discussion to do a few games in australia fyi i think as early as 24/25 season

      Delete
  16. How would Eric Lindros do in today's game? Would his style of play be as effective as it was in the 90s? Or would he have to use his size in other ways?

    ReplyDelete
  17. Given their off season signings and their kids being a year older, any reason to think that the Kings can't contend for a playoff spot this year in a bad Pacific division?

    ReplyDelete
  18. Could you make a team based on the free agents available today, assuming no salary cap, that would be better than Seattle or Buffalo?

    ReplyDelete
  19. If you could take any winger from history, scaled to today's game, to play with McDavid, who would it be? (And why is it Pavel Bure)

    ReplyDelete
  20. I know you've shot down the pick your opponent playoffs many times before, and for good reason. I wonder if it work if the NHL got rid of conference seeding and made it 1-16 qualify. If Tampa finished 1st and in 15th and 16th was Vancouver and Seattle while 14th was the Rangers or a more local team, there's almost no way Tampa would choose to travel across the country for a first round series which could give the intrigue necessary for it to actually work. What say you?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't think the NHL will ever do the pick your oppenent, but they should go with the European Champions League Draw show every year before the playoffs. Have 4 pots -- Top 4 teams in pot 1, next 4 in pot 2, etc. Then have each team have a celebrity/alumni come do the draw. Randomly pick a team in pot 1 to play a team in pot 4, pot 2 teams play pot 3. It could be an awesome 60 minutes of tv to lead into the playoffs.

      Delete
  21. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Hey Sean,

    I know the current version of the mailbag is up, but here’s one I have been mulling over, so maybe fodder for a future edition…

    Besides the well-established fact that Bettman is Satan, and lives only to make hockey fans suffer, what are any actual legitimate reasons the league doesn’t adopt a 3-2-1 points system (with 0 for an OT/shootout loss) or something similar?

    Is there a good reason, or just because the league hates it’s fans with the intensity of a thousand burning suns? To me, that’s the only reason the shootout exists…

    ReplyDelete
  23. Hi Sean! I've been listening to the Athletic's Football Cliches - podcast (where they talk about the lighter side of soccer) and some time ago they talked about players, that whom you would always refer to by their full names, never just the surname. Daniel Alfredsson, never just Alfredsson. Can you create a competitive starting lineup by only using current players? And you can't use siblings (Brady/Matthew Tkachuk).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm confused. How is it that Daniel Alfredsson was never referred to as Alfredsson? I look up highlights on YouTube and the play-by-play guys don't say "Daniel" every time he touches the puck. "Spezza to Alfredsson. Alfredsson scores!"

      Delete
  24. Hey Sean, what stat would you like to know, but no records are kept of it?
    For example, I would love to know what the longest delayed penalty ever was, but nobody's kept track of that.

    ReplyDelete
  25. My prediction is that Phil Kessel will win the Stanley Cup, again, this year. My question is what team? He will be traded before deadline, which team will step up and get Phil his third cup?

    ReplyDelete
  26. Why the hell did the Avs sign Jack Johnson

    ReplyDelete
  27. Hi Sean. Some of my favourite sports content is the Thinking Basketball channel, which breaks down historical NBA players' games via both analytics and video breakdown. I know hockey is a lot more random chaos + blind luck than basketball but, still - will we ever see something similar for hockey? Is it possible to compare, for example, Theoren Fleury and Doug Gilmore by their specific on-ice skillsets? (Rather than just scrolling "Top 10 Hart voting" for every year that those guys played?)

    ReplyDelete
  28. If you had to make a starting 5 of just one current NHL player, which player would it be and why?

    ReplyDelete
  29. Which NHL player would have done the best had they focused on one of the other 3 major sports?

    ReplyDelete
  30. Stuart Skinner is playing lights out, but in the smallest possible sample. At what point should fans consider coming out of the fetal position and watching from their sofas when a rookie goaltender is in their net? -Lowetide

    ReplyDelete
  31. Andrew Mangiapane: he's very good at both ends of the ice, plays PK and PP, can play both wings and currently only trails Leon Draisaitl in goals. 2 more than McDavid who is the 2nd highest Canadian goal scorer. It seemed like a nice gesture and nothing more when buzz was that he made hockey Canada's 50 man list for the Olympics, but do we think we are getting to the point where it could actually happen?

    ReplyDelete
  32. What are some tweaks that could be made to goaltender equipment to help increase scoring? Two blockers instead of a glove? No stick for a goalie?

    ReplyDelete
  33. Is Jack Campbell being considered for the American Olympic team (even as a third stringer)

    ReplyDelete
  34. In games played in Canada, the Calgary Flames are 3-3-4 with 3 shutouts as of this posting (Nov 22). When will they win a game in Canada where they actually give up a goal?

    (Question asked in honor of the anniversary of the game between two of the most offensively inept teams in NHL history. In 1928-29 George Hainsworth of the Montreal Canadiens posted 22 shutouts and 22 wins in 44 games. Somehow, Joe Miller of the same year's Pittsburgh Pirates had it even worse - he finished with 11 shutouts but only 9 wins. So not one but two teams whose goaltenders finished the season with shutout totals greater than or equal to their win totals. Of course the November 22, 1928 game where Montreal played in Pittsburgh finished in a 0-0 tie.)

    ReplyDelete
  35. Watching McDavid dance through entire NHL teams got me thinking, if Canada decided to put just him and a goalie out on the ice for a shift when they play team China, could he score a goal?

    ReplyDelete
  36. As of Tuesday morning, the Calgary Flames have the most points in the Western Conference, and are winless against the Western Conference. They have rampaged through the East (11-1-2) and have somehow have played more games against both the Atlantic (6) and Metropolitan (8) divisions than they have against their own conference (5). My question is: What was the NHL schedule maker smoking?

    ReplyDelete
  37. Games that can be played online, with the help of the internet are often touted as online games. These games are played with the help of a computer and will require a feasible internet connection. The arena of online games is quite vast and is largely beyond the scope of 500 words, yet the author intents to pen down some of the important aspects of online gaming. There are many reasons so as to why online games are much preferred to offline games, we shall be looking into some of them too in this article. https://www.buyyoutubesubscribers.in/

    ReplyDelete
  38. Rank all Toronto Maple Leaf OT playoff goals since the 93 season.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Couple of St. Louis Blues questions, entirely unrelated. First, a what-if: back in 1996, what would've happened to that iteration of the Blues had they kept Gretzky over Keenan? Second, among active players, where do you rank Charlie Lindgren's 'stache?

    ReplyDelete
  40. What is your favourite NHL-related stocking stuffer you ever received? I had a pack of NHL playing cards. They were awesome.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Back in the olden days when we still thought the NHLers were going to the Olympics, me and my roommates were arguing over whether Canada could score a goal of it was just McDavid and a goalie against a full team China line. Thoughts?

    ReplyDelete
  42. Who's your favorite one season wonder? Let's call it the Jonathan Cheechoo - award, because he might be mine.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Vegas just put on a few All Star Skills Competitions that were tailor made for that market with the Fountain Faceoff and the 21 in 22 events. What unique events could we get for other markets? Attempting to shoot pucks at oxygen tanks in the Jaws of sharks in San Jose? Some kind of classic Nintendo Duck Hunt but with shooting pucks in Anaheim?

    ReplyDelete
  44. Hii,
    This is great and awesome post for me. i loved to read your blog. it's really-really amazing. thanks for inspired me by your blog.Buy YouTube Subscriber

    ReplyDelete
  45. Which realistic first round opponent would be the most satisfying for the Leaf's to beat? Which opponent would the funniest to lose to?

    ReplyDelete
  46. Evgenii Dadonov would have had to pay around 500k in additional income taxes had he been traded to Anaheim. I imagine this was in the hopper of reasons why Anaheim was on his no trade list. Do you think a salary cap and player compensation structure that quantitatively relates to local taxes rates makes sense?

    ReplyDelete
  47. Do you cut your spaghetti?

    ReplyDelete
  48. You just wrote about theories why a Canadian team has not won the cup in almost 30 years.

    What sort of galactic alignment or other conditions would be needed for a Canadian team to win within the next 2 years to keep it at 30 years or less? How much more extreme are the circumstances for Toronto to win?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Other than cumulative Canadian team wins.

      Delete
  49. If by some chance a Canadian team won a conference final next year, would you recommend they touch the trophy or not?

    ReplyDelete
  50. What will be the reason for the next controversially/annoyingly overturned goal in a Stanley Cup Final? Could it all be avoided if the NHL just listened to you?

    ReplyDelete
  51. If Tampa Bay wins again, what's the go to excuse as to why *this* cup is *also* illegitimate?

    ReplyDelete
  52. Any player who is part of 4 Stanley Cup winners is clearly a good player. Stanley Cup champs can't afford passengers. That being said, would Pat Maroon be the worst 4-time cup champ who won with two different teams since the 1980s and Billy Carroll?

    ReplyDelete
  53. Summertime roster construction idea: Team Superlative Body Features vs Team Superlative Niche Skills. 3F-2D-1G. Team Superlative Body: tallest, heaviest, shortest, lightest, biggest arms, biggest legs etc. vs. Team Superlative Skills: hardest shot, fastest skater, best fighter, best goalie puck handler, best post-game cliche giver etc.

    ReplyDelete
  54. What % of goal pucks are collected for player milestones? I feel like it used to just be first NHL goal, or century milestones. Now it seems like every player needs a room dedicated to stacks of taped up pucks. What’s the most trivial milestone deserving a collection?

    ReplyDelete
  55. You mentioned on Puck Soup that you wished Colorado Edmonton went more than 4 games. What are the best playoff series (modern and historical) that only went 4 or 5 games, or the series that absolutely deserved more games based on the teams that were playing?

    ReplyDelete
  56. Why are people so quick to say there are asterisks on the two Tampa Cups when you talk about success and comparisons to Hawks/Penguins, but never want to remember that the Hawks '13 cup was less games then either of the last two seasons?

    ReplyDelete
  57. Does Tampa Bay have the most points of any team ever to reach the final and not have home ice in any round?

    ReplyDelete
  58. How many players do the Leafs loose to waivers this next season?

    ReplyDelete
  59. Do we win the cup if #99 gets tossed? I kind of think we do but then again the Habs seemed like they had the hockey gods behind them with the OT streak? Also, which Leaf do the Habs call for the stick measurement. I will now try to get on with my life. Thanks, Steve

    ReplyDelete
  60. Should the NHL introduce a 30-second penalty for puck over the glass? This would allow for one offensive faceoff/possession which seems equal to the opportunity lost.

    ReplyDelete
  61. What would the sport of hockey look like if the rules suddenly changed to give each player two shorter sticks instead of one full length stick? What sort of player would benefit the most from that fundamental change? Would it make it easier to play offense, or easier to play defense? Would it change offensive zone strategies in any way? Would most NHL players be good enough to get off a quality shot with one hand on a shorter stick?

    ReplyDelete
  62. Would it be better if the icing rule was changed so that it is determined by your defensive blue line instead of the red line? This would preserve the purpose of the rule, which is to discourage dumping the puck down the ice from your own zone, while eliminating the annoying icing calls on missed neutral zone passes.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Accidentally commented as anonymous there. Replying to attach my name to the comment.

      Delete
  63. Could they make the ice surface crystal clear and then sell seats under the ice?

    ReplyDelete
  64. When was the last time an NHL team move cities mid-season? And could it happen this year if the Arizona State Coyotes arena deal gets shot down? Playing in a college rink will be fun for a game or two, but it's going to look terrible on TV after a week. How much more embarrassment can this franchise take in this market?

    ReplyDelete
  65. Andrew DesmaraisJuly 24, 2022 at 9:36 PM

    Has anyone ever had a worse off-season (when you state you have a goal for the team, then fail to move towards that goal) than Chuck Fletcher?

    ReplyDelete
  66. Who is the worst GM in the league today, and why is it Chuck Fletcher?

    ReplyDelete
  67. Sean- article idea for you (as only you can do it): team of All time greats; left shot team versus right shot team.
    Goalies may be thin pickings for team Left shots

    ReplyDelete
  68. What’s the best team you can assemble from players who wore a number that matches their overall draft position?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oops didn’t mean to post this anonymously.

      Delete
  69. What does future considerations actually entail? Are there any interesting examples of future considerations turning into useful players?

    ReplyDelete
  70. Did the Ottawa senators win the Erik Karlsson trade?

    ReplyDelete
  71. What is the best intermission on-ice entertainment?

    ReplyDelete
  72. Over/under 0 for Johnny Gaudreau’s plus/minus for the year?

    ReplyDelete
  73. Terrific work! That is the type of information that should be shared across the internet. 메이저사이트

    ReplyDelete
  74. "Outstanding post, I think people should learn a lot from this web blog its very user pleasant.

    먹튀검증
    바카라사이트

    ReplyDelete
  75. Do we need position quotas to get more goalies in?

    ReplyDelete
  76. What players are in the HOF that shouldn’t be?

    ReplyDelete
  77. How many more female players does the hall need to induct before the women's game is properly represented? Would you be in favour of a one-time mass induction of female players to rectify the unbalance?

    ReplyDelete
  78. People love to use the quip, "It's not the Hall of Very Good," but does anyone care that it's not called the "Hall of Great" either? Have we been evaluating wrongly all along? Shouldn't we induct players to the Hall of Fame based on how famous they are, not how great at hockey they are? Who are your top picks for a hypothetical very exclusive literal Hall of *Fame*?

    ReplyDelete
  79. Marvelous! Thank you for your good information website. We also introduce our website. 먹튀검증

    ReplyDelete